GTA 6 has a 99/100 Metascore based on 152 critic reviews, but its Metacritic user score stood at just 5.6/10 from 58,121 ratings when Game News Plus checked on November 21, 2026. The contrast gives Grand Theft Auto VI one of the sharpest early splits between professional reviews and audience scoring around a major release.
These are snapshot figures, not permanent scores. Both aggregates can move as Metacritic adds eligible critic reviews and more users submit ratings. The live Metacritic page had already changed rapidly during the game’s first days, with the user average rising from the earlier 5.1 shown in initial coverage to 5.6 by our November 21 check.
What negative GTA 6 user reviews are criticizing
A sample of negative Metacritic user posts and reports from Insider Gaming and Push Square points to several recurring complaints. Some reviewers call the story disappointing, object to 30 FPS performance, or say the slower domestic tasks and other activities become repetitive. Others argue that the relationship systems and structured objectives limit the gameplay freedom they expected from Grand Theft Auto.
Jason and Lucia are another dividing point. Some user reviews criticize their characterization and relationship dynamic, while other players defend the pair and say their development becomes clearer after the opening chapters. These comments reflect individual opinions. Game News Plus has not independently verified the technical claims contained in user reviews, and a Metacritic rating alone does not establish how long—or whether—the person submitting it played the game.
Review-bombing claims remain unconfirmed
Both reports raised the possibility that GTA 6 is being review-bombed, particularly because of the volume of extreme scores submitted soon after launch. That allegation has not been confirmed, however, and the gap by itself does not prove a coordinated campaign. It may reflect a mix of genuine dissatisfaction, polarized reactions, protest ratings, and the low barrier to posting a user score.
The response is not uniformly negative. Positive critic and user reviews praise GTA 6’s visuals, extraordinary world detail, and sense of immersion, with some describing Leonida as a new benchmark for open-world design. The 99 Metascore also remains intact in this snapshot, now across 152 reviews rather than the 109 counted when we first reported GTA 6’s record-tying Metacritic debut.
With tens of thousands of audience ratings arriving in a short period, the user average may continue to change as more people finish the game and add their verdicts.
Featured image: Game News Plus.
What do you think best explains the gap between GTA 6’s 99 critic score and its much lower user score?





Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.